The First 90 Days Can Determine Whether a New Credit Card Becomes Top-of-Wallet

16537

When a credit card application is approved, it may seem like the hard work is over. For community banks and credit unions, however, approval is only the beginning. The real challenge is turning a newly issued card into the one a customer uses most often.

The journey typically moves from approval to activation, then to regular spending and, ultimately, top-of-wallet status. A card that is activated but rarely used may never recover the cost of acquiring the customer. Premium card programs can require substantial investment in introductory rewards, while even a standard card may cost as much as $250 to acquire a new account. If cardholders do not use the product consistently, it can take as long as three years for the account to become profitable.

That makes the first 90 days after approval a critical period. During this window, customers form early habits that can determine whether the card becomes their first choice for everyday purchases or disappears into a drawer.

Key Takeaways

  • Approval is only the first milestone. A new card can cost up to $250 to acquire and may take years to become profitable without regular use.
  • Reducing the time to first purchase is essential. Early digital wallet enrollment can help customers begin spending sooner.
  • Welcome bonuses may drive initial applications and purchases, but they do not always create lasting usage habits.
  • Customer communications should respond to cardholder behavior rather than follow a rigid calendar.
  • Slow first use, longer gaps between purchases and declining spending can signal that a card is becoming inactive.

Closing the Gap Between Approval and First Use

One of the biggest obstacles for financial institutions is getting customers to use a card for the first time. The experience immediately after approval can influence whether initial excitement turns into action.

“The experience immediately after approval is really important. You’re trying to make it as easy as possible for someone to actually start using the card,” Nola Ogunyemi, senior vice president of consumer lending at BECU, told The Financial Brand.

Allowing cardholders to add a new card to a digital wallet before the physical card arrives can remove a major barrier. Customers can begin using the account through a smartphone or other connected device instead of waiting several days for delivery.

“The longer you make someone wait, the more opportunity there is for that excitement and intent to fade,” Ogunyemi said.

Kevin Smith, president of digital marketing agency Mighty Roar, recommends introducing digital wallet enrollment as soon as the technology permits. Ideally, customers should see a clear “add to wallet” option during mobile app setup or immediately after approval.

Some institutions introduce wallet enrollment as part of a broader onboarding sequence rather than making it the first message customers receive. Megan Smith, vice president of marketing and communications at Trumark Credit Union, said the organization first welcomes new cardholders and introduces the card’s rewards and benefits before following up with information about digital wallets and card controls.

Trumark also supports customers who collect their cards at a branch. Member service representatives can help add the card to a mobile wallet before the customer leaves, allowing the account to be used immediately.

Digital wallet enrollment, however, should not be treated as the final goal. The more important objective is connecting the card to a purchase the customer already makes.

“Give the cardmember a clear reason to use the card for a purchase they already make, whether that’s groceries, gas, or another regular expense that fits the card’s benefits,” Kevin Smith said.

Why Welcome Bonuses Are Not Enough

Introductory rewards can encourage a first transaction, but they do not always create long-term loyalty. Research from the Auriemma Group indicates that about 33% of credit cardholders have at least one card they have not used during the previous six months. In 2025, 30% of cardholders said sign-up bonuses were the main reason they acquired cards that later became inactive, compared with 22% in 2023.

These figures highlight a common problem: a promotional offer may generate short-term activity without changing the customer’s everyday payment habits.

“An introductory offer can absolutely give someone a reason to make that first purchase, but you don’t want to have to keep paying someone to use your card,” Ogunyemi said. “After that initial transaction, the value needs to be relevant to how they already spend.”

For long-term success, banks and credit unions need to show customers why the card remains useful after the welcome promotion ends. The most effective message will depend on the type of card and the customer’s spending preferences.

  • Cash-back cards: Explain how customers can earn cash back across different spending categories and how to redeem their rewards.
  • Rewards cards: Demonstrate how to accumulate points faster and outline the available redemption options.
  • Lower-rate cards: Emphasize the value of a reduced interest rate and explain features such as balance transfers.

Trumark also promotes reward redemption after eligible purchases. Customers may receive a text message or email asking whether they want to apply their points. Once they confirm, the points are applied automatically.

Making rewards simple to understand and easy to use can reinforce the card’s value. It also gives institutions another opportunity to engage customers after the first purchase.

Kevin Smith recommends testing different incentives to determine which ones produce repeat purchases. Financial institutions should also monitor customer behavior after a promotion expires.

If spending stops as soon as a reward ends, the institution may have created a temporary response instead of a lasting habit. Promotions should help customers discover the card’s everyday value, not encourage the bank or credit union to pay repeatedly for the same behavior.

Use Customer Behavior to Guide Outreach

Effective onboarding should be based on what cardholders do, not simply on how many days have passed since approval.

“The best outreach isn’t necessarily based on a calendar, it’s based on what the cardmember is doing,” Ogunyemi said.

Trumark uses a 90-day early-life strategy that separates customers who have activated their cards from those who have not. This approach allows the institution to send more relevant messages instead of delivering the same campaign to every new cardholder.

Structured rewards onboarding can have a measurable impact. Data from ampliFI found that cardholders who received organized rewards education experienced a 32.4% increase in card use during the first 90 days. The same group recorded 30.2% higher spending after 12 months than control groups.

Timing and coordination are also important. A customer who has already activated a card should not receive another activation reminder. Messages that do not reflect the customer’s actions can make the institution appear disconnected from the relationship it is trying to build.

New cardholders may receive communications from several campaigns at the same time, including promotional offers, product education and general onboarding messages. Financial institutions should coordinate these efforts so that customers receive a consistent experience across email, text messages, mobile apps and other channels.

Behavior-based communication can also help institutions identify customers who may be at risk of abandoning the card. Waiting until a card becomes completely inactive can limit the opportunity to re-engage the customer.

Early Warning Signs of Card Disengagement

Several patterns may indicate that a card is unlikely to become a customer’s preferred payment method:

  • No first purchase within 30 days of activation.
  • A lengthy gap between the first and second purchases.
  • Heavy early spending that stops after the welcome offer is completed.
  • Declining purchase frequency during the second or third month.
  • No rewards activity or redemption.
  • Limited interaction with the financial institution.

When these signals appear, banks and credit unions should use targeted follow-up messages. A customer may need help adding the card to a digital wallet, understanding rewards or locating card controls. In other cases, the right response may be a reminder about benefits connected to routine expenses.

“We don’t want to wait until a card becomes inactive to try to re-engage someone,” Megan Smith said.

Making the First 90 Days Count

Many cards become inactive because the first purchase takes too long, customers do not receive enough guidance about ongoing benefits or early warning signs are overlooked. The first 90 days offer a valuable opportunity to influence future payment behavior.

Community banks and credit unions that simplify activation, promote digital wallet use, connect the card to everyday spending and tailor communications to customer behavior are more likely to build lasting engagement.

The strongest card onboarding strategies do more than deliver a welcome offer. They help customers understand the product, use it quickly and discover enough ongoing value to make it the card they reach for first.

Source: TheFinancialBrand.com