Why Member Success Could Be the Revenue Growth Strategy Banks and Credit Unions Are Missing

16527

A member visits a branch to deposit a check. During the transaction, she mentions that her daughter has been accepted into college. The teller congratulates her, completes the deposit and moves on to the next customer waiting in line.

The interaction appears successful, but an important opportunity has been missed. No one asks how the family plans to pay for tuition, whether they need financial guidance or if the member may benefit from a college savings product or loan.

The teller completed the assigned task. The branch simply did not create enough time for the conversation that could have followed.

Missed Conversations Can Lead to Missed Revenue

These missed moments are becoming more costly for financial institutions. J.D. Power’s 2026 U.S. Retail Banking Satisfaction Study found that the average checking customer now maintains deposit accounts with three different institutions. The study also reported that 20% of customers moved money from their primary bank during the previous three months, compared with 17% the year before.

J.D. Power describes this behavior as “soft switching” and identifies declining satisfaction with personal service as a warning sign. A member may not leave because of one unanswered question about college expenses. However, repeated experiences in which staff fail to recognize or address emerging needs can encourage members to open accounts elsewhere.

Throughout my 16-year career, I have worked in roles where customer care and business growth were closely connected. My experience spans retail, enterprise technology and banking. I believe member success is one of the most effective revenue engines available to credit unions and community banks.

The same activities that help members achieve their financial goals can also improve satisfaction, strengthen loyalty and increase revenue.

What Starbucks Taught Me About Branch Performance

Many of these lessons began during my nearly seven years running and managing one of the busiest Starbucks locations in the Southeast. The store processed approximately 1,200 transactions each day, and annual revenue increased from $3 million to $4.5 million.

Most customers entered with a single purchase in mind. Yet a thoughtful question, a strong understanding of regular customers or a simple suggestion often led to an additional purchase. Repeating that approach throughout the day created a meaningful impact on revenue.

The operating model had much in common with branch management. A large part of my role involved managing traffic, staffing the right people for peak periods and ensuring the team could serve customers without becoming overwhelmed.

When the store had adequate coverage, employees could engage customers and identify opportunities to help. When staffing was thin, the team focused only on completing transactions. The quality of the interaction suffered, and valuable conversations never took place.

Service, Sales and Client Success Are Connected

After Starbucks, I founded a company and quickly saw how customer satisfaction affected financial performance. When a customer is unhappy, the consequences can appear in revenue almost immediately.

I later moved into sales and account management in enterprise technology, working with organizations including Google, Rolls-Royce and Pinterest. New business was important, but the most dependable growth came from existing customers who trusted us and continued expanding their relationships.

My experience leading client success teams reinforced the importance of delivering a consistent experience. Every organization has employees whom customers naturally appreciate. The larger challenge is creating systems that make outstanding service possible regardless of which employee happens to be working.

Credit unions and community banks have an advantage because members still visit their branches. The opportunity is to make every visit more useful, personal and relevant.

Four Principles for Turning Member Success Into Growth

1. Be curious about every member

A curious banker does more than process a request. They ask why the member came in, what has changed in their life and what financial need may come next.

These questions can uncover opportunities involving loans, new accounts, savings plans and long-term financial relationships. They also help members feel recognized and valued.

Research cited by PYMNTS in its Credit Union Tracker with Velera found that 76% of Gen Z consumers are likely to act on personalized guidance received during an in-branch conversation. Many successful banking opportunities begin with a question that employees were not required to ask.

The problem is that frontline employees often lack the time to ask it.

2. Give employees the time to engage

Most financial institutions already employ people who could excel at meaningful member conversations. Their schedules, however, are often dominated by unexpected walk-ins, shift coverage issues, manual processes and rushed handoffs.

Solving that problem requires more than encouraging employees to provide better service. Banks and credit unions need operational processes and workforce tools that reduce daily disruption and give staff the capacity to focus on members.

When branch operations become more organized, employee engagement, member satisfaction and revenue can improve together.

3. Build trust through consistent service

People are more likely to purchase products and follow advice from professionals they consider credible. In banking, credibility comes from taking ownership of the member’s outcome, arriving prepared, following through and delivering a dependable experience.

Trust is created during service interactions. It makes future conversations easier and increases the likelihood that members will return for additional financial guidance. For that reason, client success should be viewed as a revenue function rather than a support activity.

4. Make member success a shared mindset

Some organizations treat client success as a department that resolves problems after they occur. In a branch, however, member success should be part of the entire team’s approach to service, advice and relationship building.

Creating a new client success role will not automatically change results. Leaders and employees must consistently adopt the mindset, reinforce the behaviors and build member success into everyday branch operations.

Branch Health Creates Room for Better Conversations

Financial institutions cannot expect employees to be curious when their entire day is reactive. If leaders want staff to understand members more deeply, they must create systems that make those conversations possible.

This need is becoming more important as branch visits evolve. A Santander US survey of middle-income Americans found that 89% want to complete most banking tasks digitally while still having access to a physical branch with knowledgeable employees when personal help is needed.

Credit unions are responding to this shift. Wipfli research cited by PYMNTS found that 76% of credit union executives planning to repurpose branches intend to transform them into advisory hubs.

A redesigned branch alone will not create better member experiences. Daily operations, staffing and planning determine whether employees have enough time to provide advice.

Four Ways to Improve Branch Performance

Know who is visiting and why

Employees who only learn about a member’s needs after the conversation begins have little time to prepare. Appointment scheduling allows staff to see who is expected, understand the purpose of the visit and assign the right employee in advance.

Members also tend to adopt appointment scheduling after experiencing the convenience. Data from one credit union showed scheduled visits increasing from slightly more than half of branch traffic in 2020 to 86% in 2025.

Manage lobby traffic effectively

Unpredictable wait times and sudden walk-in surges quickly push branch teams into reactive mode. Lobby management tools can improve traffic flow, reduce uncertainty for members and give employees more control over longer conversations.

Align staffing with member needs

A branch may have enough employees on the floor during its busiest period but still lack the right mix of skills. For example, several employees may be available for routine transactions while no one is prepared to discuss a complex loan or financial planning need.

Workforce scheduling should consider both expected traffic and the types of conversations members have booked. This helps ensure that the right expertise is available at the right time.

Track branch performance data

Leaders need visibility into traffic patterns, outcomes, staffing levels and opportunities by location. Without reliable data, each branch develops its own habits, creating inconsistent experiences for members across the network.

These measures work best as a complete system. Appointment scheduling without lobby management solves only part of the problem. Staffing without performance data can still leave critical gaps. Together, these capabilities help branches plan ahead and create more time for meaningful conversations.

What a Healthy Branch Looks Like

A healthy branch delivers benefits for members, employees and the institution. It:

  • Retains employees by allowing them to spend more time on meaningful work.
  • Creates more opportunities for members by giving staff the context and time to ask better questions.
  • Reduces the administrative effort required to build schedules and manage coverage.
  • Becomes the first place members turn to for important financial decisions.

When branch operations support these outcomes, member success becomes part of the institution’s growth strategy rather than a separate service initiative.

Member Success Is a Growth Strategy

Many financial institutions still classify member service as an expense while searching for growth through other channels. In reality, substantial growth opportunities may already be present in the branch lobby.

Leaders at credit unions and community banks should consider the following questions:

  • How much of each frontline employee’s day is reactive rather than planned?
  • Do bankers know who is scheduled to visit and what each member needs?
  • During the busiest hours, is the right employee available for the most important conversations?
  • When a member mentions a major life event, does anyone have time to follow up?

If the answers are difficult, the institution is not alone. In many cases, the issue is not a lack of commitment from employees. It is a lack of operational capacity.

Once branch processes are organized and employees have the time to engage, member satisfaction and revenue can rise together. Curiosity starts the conversation, trust strengthens the relationship and member success creates sustainable growth.

Sean O’Neill is Head of Growth at FMSI, a provider of branch performance and workforce management solutions for banks and credit unions. His 16-year career has connected customer experience with account growth, beginning with his work as a Starbucks store manager.

Source: Thefinancialbrand.com