Why Banks Struggle to Turn Customer Data Into Sustainable Growth

16542

Financial institutions have spent years building detailed views of their customers and members. What began with basic demographic profiles and market segments has expanded to include transaction histories, behavioral patterns, product usage and real-time financial signals.

That wealth of information should make it easier for banks and credit unions to strengthen relationships, identify customer needs and increase revenue. In practice, many institutions still struggle to turn customer intelligence into measurable growth.

The challenge is not simply a lack of data. Organizational silos, conflicting business goals, disconnected technology systems and outdated marketing strategies often prevent institutions from acting on what they know. As artificial intelligence becomes more capable, banks will need to rethink not only their technology but also the way they manage customer relationships.

Generative AI and agentic AI could help institutions connect customer insights with more accurate product recommendations, personalized offers and faster decision-making. At the same time, consumer-facing AI agents are creating new competitive and security pressures for traditional banks.

To better understand the issue, The Financial Brand spoke with Carson Kotnyek, Head of GTM and Advisory at Zafin.

Break Down Internal Banking Silos

Many banks are organized around separate lines of business that have developed independently over many years. Mortgage, deposits, cards, wealth management and commercial banking divisions may each use different platforms, sales strategies and performance targets.

This structure makes it difficult for any single team to manage the complete customer relationship. It can also create incentives that conflict with the institution’s broader goals.

“Most of the time, line of business incentives do not ladder up to a shared metric of success for the bank,” Kotnyek said. “So they end up driving conflicting incentives for the customer that do not serve the bank’s interest.”

For example, a customer may hold a mortgage, business checking account and credit card with the same institution. Yet each business unit may communicate with that individual according to its own objectives. One team may focus on increasing deposits, another on promoting lending products and a third on card spending.

The result can be inconsistent messaging, overlapping campaigns and offers that fail to reflect the customer’s complete financial relationship. Brand presentation may even differ between products, creating confusion and weakening trust.

These disconnects can also cause banks to miss important growth opportunities. A customer’s savings activity may indicate plans to purchase a home, but the deposit team may have little motivation or ability to share that insight with mortgage specialists.

Financial institutions do not necessarily need to replace every existing product platform to address the problem. A more practical starting point is a coordinated relationship strategy supported by shared performance measures. Metrics such as total asset growth, retention, household profitability and relationship depth can help business units work toward common goals.

Build Value Around the Entire Customer Relationship

Relationship-based rewards programs offer another way to align customer needs with institutional priorities. Instead of limiting rewards to credit card purchases, banks can design programs that recognize the full value of a customer’s deposits, investments, borrowing and payment activity.

Loyalty programs have long been used in financial services to encourage card spending and increase engagement. Research cited in the original report found that more than 60% of surveyed U.S. card issuers and fintech companies said rewards programs increased total spending, while 66% reported higher card usage.

Industry research has also indicated that high-performing loyalty programs can raise annual revenue from participating customers by between 15% and 25%. These results help explain why more financial institutions are exploring broad relationship programs rather than treating loyalty as a credit card feature alone.

“Banks are starting to see the potential,” Kotnyek said. “They are thinking about loyalty as not just credit card points but as a holistic program.”

Several major institutions and fintech companies have introduced models that reward customers for consolidating more of their financial lives with one provider:

  • Bank of America Rewards: The program, previously known as Preferred Rewards, offers benefit levels based on combined balances held in bank deposits and Merrill investment accounts. Higher tiers can include benefits such as subscription credits, event access and other lifestyle rewards.
  • PNC TotalRewards: Introduced in 2026, the program uses banking and investment balances to determine membership levels. Customers can receive enhanced savings rates, stronger card rewards and cash incentives connected to qualifying mortgage and auto loans.
  • Revolut subscriptions: The fintech offers different paid membership levels that combine financial benefits with lifestyle services. Features may include improved savings rates, lower international transfer fees, larger ATM allowances, travel advantages and third-party subscriptions.

Relationship programs can also encourage customers to remain with an institution for a longer period. Kotnyek described an example in which a bank matches 1% of a $100,000 investment transfer and distributes the $1,000 reward over 12 months. The delayed payout gives the customer a reason to maintain the relationship while the institution builds deeper engagement.

Prepare for Competition From AI Financial Agents

The growth of personal AI agents capable of assisting with financial tasks is adding another layer of urgency for banks. These tools may eventually compare rates, move funds, manage payments and complete other transactions on behalf of consumers and businesses.

Some institutions are responding by emphasizing the security risks associated with allowing external agents to access accounts. Those concerns are valid, especially when an AI tool is authorized to initiate payments or make other high-impact decisions.

However, blocking AI agents entirely may not be a sustainable long-term strategy. Businesses, particularly small and midsized companies, may increasingly rely on automated tools to manage payroll, transfers and other routine financial operations.

“Blocking agents due to security risk is totally valid but it is not going to be a long-term answer,” Kotnyek said. He questioned whether a business would remain with a bank that prevents authorized agents from accessing its accounts when those tools provide important operating efficiencies.

Financial institutions with strong relationship programs may be better positioned to protect customer loyalty in an agent-driven marketplace. However, their benefits, pricing rules and customer-specific advantages must be available to authorized AI systems in a secure, machine-readable format.

An AI agent that is helping a customer optimize finances needs to understand the complete relationship. If it sees only an account’s interest rate or transaction fee, it may recommend moving money elsewhere without considering rewards, discounts, relationship pricing or other benefits available through the bank.

Strengthen AI Governance Before Expanding Automation

As banks use AI to turn customer data into personalized offers and automated actions, governance will become increasingly important. Institutions must define what each AI system can access, what decisions it can make and when human approval is required.

This is especially critical when agents handle sensitive financial information or influence prices, credit decisions and product recommendations. A governance framework should include the following practices:

  • Confirm the identity and authority of every AI agent.
  • Apply policies and controls while tasks are being performed.
  • Use consistent governance standards across systems and operating environments.
  • Escalate significant decisions to employees who have the necessary context.
  • Track and manage the cost of AI operations.
  • Record every significant agent action and decision for audit purposes.
  • Manage the full agent lifecycle and prevent uncontrolled growth in automated systems.

Several principles should guide this approach. Governance needs to cover the entire workflow rather than focusing only on the AI agent. Restrictions must be enforceable in real time, and human authority must be integrated directly into the process. Audit records should also be created as work occurs, rather than reconstructed later.

These safeguards are particularly important when AI generates customer offers. Banks must be able to explain why a customer received a particular price, rate or incentive. They also need to demonstrate why two similar customers may have received different offers.

AI Growth Depends on Trust and Control

Artificial intelligence gives financial institutions a powerful opportunity to connect customer insights with timely actions. Yet better technology alone will not solve the relationship problems created by disconnected teams and competing incentives.

Banks that want to benefit from AI will need shared business objectives, relationship-based value propositions and clear rules for automated decision-making. Some AI agents may operate independently with read-only access to customer data, while others may require employee approval before changing prices or initiating transactions.

As automated systems demonstrate reliability, institutions can gradually expand their authority within carefully defined limits. This approach allows banks to automate more complex work while maintaining control over decisions that affect customers, revenue and trust.

Bottom line: The institutions most likely to convert customer knowledge into sustainable growth will be those that combine data, organizational alignment, meaningful relationship benefits and strong AI governance.

Source: Thefinancialbrand.com