By Corey Wrinn, Managing Director of Rivel Banking Research
Research Spending Should Follow Business Risk
There is no universal research budget that works for every bank or credit union.
An institution entering a new market, repositioning its brand or investing heavily in a new product requires a different level of market intelligence than an organization carrying out a proven strategy with reliable data already available.
Instead of asking, “How much should we spend on research?” financial institutions should begin with a more useful question:
“How much of our marketing budget are we prepared to commit based on assumptions we have not yet proven?”
The answer should help shape the research budget for the coming year.
What Bank Marketing Budget Benchmarks Show
Banks generally allocate between 0.05% and 0.07% of total assets to marketing. Research from Capital Performance Group places the average at approximately 0.06% of assets, equal to about 2% to 4% of total noninterest expense.
Those marketing budgets support a wide range of investments, including technology, digital channels, media, sponsorships, creative development, agencies and artificial intelligence tools. The challenge is determining how much should be reserved to confirm that these investments are moving in the right direction.
As a broad planning guide, allocating 5% to 15% of the marketing budget to research, analytics and optimization may be reasonable. However, this range should not be treated as a fixed rule.
The appropriate amount depends on the decisions the institution needs to make and the uncertainty surrounding those decisions.
Build the Budget Around Decisions, Not Percentages
Before establishing a research budget, identify the most important decisions expected during the next 12 to 18 months. Consider whether your institution is:
- Entering or expanding in a new market
- Rebranding or pursuing a different audience
- Launching or repricing a product
- Experiencing rising acquisition costs without a clear explanation
- Making a major technology or customer experience investment
- Responding to a competitor that has significantly changed its strategy
These decisions carry greater risk. A poor choice could cost substantially more than the research needed to test the assumptions behind it.
Not every marketing decision requires new research, however. If recent and trustworthy data already answers the question, use that information. If campaign results clearly show which channels are producing returns, act on the evidence. When an investment is small, easy to reverse and quick to measure, an in-market test may be more valuable than a research project completed in advance.
The objective is not to maximize research activity. It is to reduce the amount of money committed to unsupported assumptions.
Use Existing Customer and Marketing Data First
Before adding a new research expense, review the information already available within the institution. Existing customer and marketing data can often answer important questions without requiring a separate study.
Useful sources may include:
- New account openings
- Customer attrition and retention data
- Product penetration
- CRM records
- Digital engagement behavior
- Search performance
- Campaign results
- Call center trends
- Customer reviews and feedback
Internal data may reveal that customer acquisition is slowing, but it may not explain why. It could show that a market is underperforming without revealing that consumers have stronger consideration for several competitors. It may identify customer departures without showing what would have persuaded those customers to stay.
Research delivers the greatest value when existing information no longer provides a clear answer.
Match Research Spending to the Dollars at Risk
Another practical way to determine the right research investment is to work backward from the amount of money the institution is trying to protect.
A small, measurable marketing test may not justify an extensive study. A major rebrand, market expansion, branch opening, product launch or large-scale campaign requires a more careful evaluation.
Ask the following questions:
- How much are we preparing to invest?
- Which assumptions must be correct for the investment to succeed?
- What could the institution lose if those assumptions are wrong?
This approach changes the discussion. Research is no longer viewed simply as a way to purchase insights. Instead, it becomes a tool for reducing uncertainty around an important business decision.
A Practical Framework for Creating a Research Budget
Before the next budgeting cycle, identify the five largest marketing or growth investments your institution expects to make. Then evaluate each one using the following framework:
- Investment: How much money is planned?
- Assumption: What must be true for the investment to succeed?
- Evidence: What existing information supports that assumption?
- Knowledge gap: What important information is missing?
- Decision impact: Would answering the question change the planned action?
If the answer to the final question is no, additional research may not be necessary. If the answer is yes, the institution has a stronger business case for research than simply claiming that a fixed percentage of the marketing budget should be allocated to it.
The Bottom Line for Bank Marketing Leaders
The purpose of a research budget is not to defend research spending. It is to increase confidence in the much larger marketing and growth investments surrounding it.
Financial institutions should use research strategically: rely on existing data where it is sufficient, investigate gaps that could materially affect a decision and focus resources on the assumptions carrying the greatest financial risk.
When research is tied to business decisions rather than arbitrary benchmarks, banks and credit unions can spend more confidently and rely less on guesswork.
Corey Wrinn is Managing Director of Rivel Banking Research, where he works with banks and credit unions to understand the customers, prospects and local markets that shape their growth strategies.
Source: TheFinancialBrand.com
日本語
한국어
Tiếng Việt
简体中文