Interchange Under Pressure: How Regulation, Fintech and New Payment Rails Are Reshaping Card Revenue

16507

By Tony DeSanctis, Cornerstone Advisors

Published November 16, 2026

For nearly 40 years, financial institutions have depended on interchange income as a reliable source of non-interest revenue. That model is now facing growing pressure as regulatory changes, fintech competition and alternative payment methods reshape the payments industry.

Interchange remains a critical revenue stream. The Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis estimates that card interchange generates approximately $66 billion annually. For many community financial institutions, it accounts for roughly 25% to 30% of non-interest income.

However, the revenue stream is being challenged from several directions at once. Banks and credit unions must prepare for lower per-transaction income, greater competition for primary banking relationships and payment options that bypass traditional card networks.

Three Forces Threatening Interchange Revenue

  • Regulatory and legal developments are increasingly favorable to merchants and could reduce issuer income.
  • Fintech companies are capturing new customers, debit cards and deposit relationships that once belonged to traditional institutions.
  • Alternative payment methods, including pay by bank, stablecoins, faster payments and buy now, pay later services, are diverting transactions from card networks.

Regulatory Changes Could Reduce Card Economics

Two major developments are creating uncertainty for interchange revenue: litigation involving debit interchange calculations and the Visa and Mastercard credit card settlement.

North Dakota Case Could Change Debit Cap Calculations

A North Dakota lawsuit involving regulated institutions with more than $10 billion in assets challenges how the debit interchange cap is calculated. Courts have indicated that only variable costs directly connected to a transaction should be included.

Under that interpretation, fixed expenses such as card production, statements and certain fraud-related costs could be excluded from the calculation. The appeals court reached a conclusion consistent with the original ruling, although additional appeals, including a possible review by the Supreme Court, remain available.

If the decision becomes the standard for regulated interchange, affected institutions could face a meaningful reduction in debit card revenue. Banks should monitor the case closely and model multiple outcomes in their financial forecasts.

Credit Card Settlement Adds More Pressure

The Visa and Mastercard credit card settlement is also expected to affect credit card interchange, card acceptance and rewards economics. The changes are anticipated to begin in 2027, making them an important consideration for upcoming budgets and long-term product planning.

Under the settlement, standard credit card interchange would be capped at 125 basis points for eight years. Depending on an issuer’s product structure and portfolio mix, that could reduce standard credit card interchange by approximately 20 to 30 basis points.

Merchants may technically be able to refuse premium products such as Visa Signature and Mastercard World Elite cards. In practice, however, merchants may be reluctant to reject a purchase simply because a customer presents a premium card. Customers may also turn to American Express, which can carry higher acceptance costs for merchants.

Rewards cards face a separate challenge. A 10-basis-point reduction in rewards interchange over five years could eventually reduce rewards interchange by an estimated 20% to 30%, creating a gradual but significant decline in portfolio profitability.

Issuers will need to decide whether to reduce rewards value, accept lower margins or redesign their rewards products to preserve customer engagement and profitability.

Fintechs Are Taking Cards and Primary Relationships

Fintech competition is affecting interchange revenue as well as the deposit relationships that support card spending. The six largest United States fintech companies, including Affirm, Klarna, SoFi, Chime, PayPal and Cash App, collectively represent more than 60 million debit cards, or about 8% of the market.

Research from Ron Shevlin at Cornerstone Advisors found that 53% of consumers opening new accounts were choosing fintech neobanks. That research was conducted before Revolut expanded further into the United States market, suggesting that competition may intensify.

The concern extends beyond the number of debit cards issued. When fintech companies become a customer’s primary financial provider, they can also capture direct deposits, everyday spending, savings balances and other activity that traditionally supported bank relationships.

Cash App, for example, has shifted its reporting emphasis from total debit cards to primary accounts. The company reported 9.4 million primary accounts in its latest quarterly earnings report, highlighting the importance of primary relationship growth in the fintech sector.

Alternative Payments Could Bypass Card Networks

New payment technologies are creating another layer of risk for card issuers. Stablecoins, faster payments, pay by bank and buy now, pay later services each have the potential to redirect transactions away from traditional card rails.

Faster payments and stablecoins may pose the greatest threat to commercial and cross-border payments. They could also affect commercial credit card usage as businesses look for faster or less expensive ways to move money.

Pay by Bank Eliminates Card Interchange

Pay by bank allows consumers to connect a checking account directly to a merchant or financial service through online banking integrations provided by companies such as Plaid. Because the transaction does not run through a card network, the card issuer receives no interchange revenue.

The impact may be particularly significant for credit cards. In addition to losing interchange, financial institutions may miss the revolving balances and loan revenue that would have resulted from a credit card transaction.

Buy Now, Pay Later Competes With Credit Cards

Buy now, pay later products also compete directly with credit cards. A financial institution may receive some interchange when a BNPL transaction is funded with a debit card, but it typically loses the higher credit card interchange and the opportunity to generate a loan balance.

As consumers use installment payment products for larger purchases, issuers could see further pressure on both card spending and credit-related revenue.

How Financial Institutions Can Respond

Model Regulatory and Legal Exposure

Institutions should quantify the possible effects of debit and credit interchange changes under multiple scenarios. Updated forecasts should account for lower rates, changes in rewards economics, portfolio composition and the timing of regulatory implementation.

Increase Card Usage and Customer Engagement

When revenue per transaction declines, growth in purchase volume becomes more important. Targeted marketing, card-linked offers, digital wallet integration and personalized spending incentives can encourage customers to use an institution’s cards more frequently.

New account growth is equally important because each new relationship can generate additional card spending, deposits and long-term revenue.

Reevaluate the Value Proposition

Fintech companies are attracting new customers at a rapid pace. Traditional institutions should review their product benefits, digital experience, pricing, onboarding process and marketing strategies to determine where they are losing ground.

A stronger value proposition can help institutions retain existing customers and compete for consumers who are opening their first or next primary account.

Develop a Payment Rail Strategy

Financial institutions should identify which emerging payment methods are most likely to affect their customer base. For some products, the best approach may be to partner with fintech providers or introduce a competing service. For others, institutions may need to emphasize the security, rewards and convenience of their existing card products.

The Outlook for Interchange Revenue

Interchange revenue is likely to decline on a per-transaction basis as legal, regulatory and competitive pressures increase. Yet the overall opportunity has not disappeared.

Institutions that grow customer relationships, increase card usage and maintain strong deposit engagement can offset some of the pressure through higher transaction volume and broader account relationships. The future of interchange will depend less on maintaining historical pricing levels and more on acquiring customers, retaining primary relationships and adapting to changing payment preferences.

For financial institutions, the interchange challenge is not limited to card revenue. It is also a fight for deposits, customer activity and long-term relevance in an increasingly fragmented payments market.

Source: TheFinancialBrand.com