日本語
한국어
Tiếng Việt
简体中文
Conspiracy theorist Alex Jones and far-right commentator Nick Fuentes briefly reappeared on YouTube, only to have their newly created accounts removed within hours. This swift action has reignited debates around platform censorship and came despite widespread anticipation that YouTube was preparing to reinstate some previously banned creators.
Rapid Takedowns Spark ‘Censorship War’ Claims
The channels, established for the prominent figures, were active for only a short period before being terminated by the video-sharing giant. Breanna Morello of Jones’s Infowars network quickly reacted to the removal, stating in a video, “The censorship war is still on it looks like. They’re trying to stop Infowars. They’re trying to stop Alex Jones.”
Nick Fuentes echoed similar sentiments on X (formerly Twitter), questioning, “Sounds a little ridiculous. Can’t we just have free speech? I’ve been banned since February 2020 when I was 21 years old.”
Confusion Surrounds YouTube’s Reinstatement Pilot Program
The brief return of Jones and Fuentes coincided with considerable speculation regarding YouTube’s content moderation policies. Earlier in the week, Rep. Jim Jordan, the Republican chair of the House Oversight Committee, shared a letter from YouTube’s parent company, Alphabet. The letter detailed an upcoming pilot program designed to allow creators banned for repeat violations of certain Covid-19 and election-related content policies (now no longer in effect) an opportunity to return.
However, Jordan’s interpretation, shared on X, appeared to overstate the program’s scope, suggesting it would “offer ALL creators previously kicked off YouTube due to political speech violations to return to the platform.” This led many on the right to anticipate a broad wave of reinstatements.
YouTube Clarifies Policy and Eligibility
YouTube moved to clarify the situation on X, explaining that the reinstatement effort had not yet begun. “We terminated these channels as it’s still against our rules for previously terminated users to start new channels,” the company stated on Thursday. “The pilot program for terminations that many people have been referencing this week isn’t available yet and will be a limited pilot program to start. We’ll have more on how the program will work, who is eligible, and how creators can access it soon.”
Crucially, it appears both Jones and Fuentes may not be eligible for the upcoming program, even once it launches. Alex Jones was originally removed from YouTube in 2018—prior to the pandemic—for violations including hate speech and child endangerment. Nick Fuentes faced his ban in 2020 for hate speech. The pilot program’s focus on Covid-19 and election-related content policies suggests a specific, rather than universal, pathway back to the platform.
Political Figures Weigh In on Content Moderation
The removals drew criticism from figures beyond those directly impacted. Vivek Ramaswamy, a former Trump administration ally and Ohio gubernatorial candidate, weighed in on X, comparing the incident to the temporary suspension of late-night host Jimmy Kimmel, which followed pressure from the Trump administration.
“Our country is at its best when we’re able to hear one another. Nick Fuentes & Jimmy Kimmel probably don’t like me, for different reasons,” Ramaswamy wrote. “I don’t care. It’s still un-American to muzzle the peaceful expression of opinions. And no, that’s not a legal point, it’s a cultural point.”