Clegg: AI Copyright Demands Could “Kill” UK Industry

Former Meta executive Sir Nick Clegg has ignited debate by claiming that proposed copyright laws demanding tech companies seek permission before using copyrighted material to train AI could devastate the UK’s AI sector.

Speaking after MPs voted against a measure to increase copyright transparency, Clegg argued that requiring permission for AI training is “unworkable” given the vast datasets already in use. He acknowledged artists’ rights to opt-out but deemed preemptive permission “implausible.”

Creative industry leaders, including Sir Elton John and Sir Paul McCartney, have voiced strong opposition, warning that such changes could jeopardize millions of livelihoods. However, Clegg, promoting his book “How to Save the Internet,” countered that demanding upfront consent would stifle innovation.

Clegg highlighted AI’s existing capabilities to generate art, emphasizing the technological challenges of implementing a consent-based system. He suggested that while opting out should be facilitated, expecting preemptive approval clashes with the fundamental workings of AI.

He also noted that unilateral implementation in the UK could cripple its AI industry. The parliamentary vote saw MPs reject an amendment focused on data transparency, underscoring the ongoing tension between fostering technological advancement and protecting creative rights.

Clegg’s remarks come after his departure from Meta earlier this year, following seven years at the company.

Tags: AI, Copyright, Nick Clegg, Meta, UK Tech Industry